Really impressed with the selection, especially with some of horror movies. I've been to similar resell shops down in Memphis and even though they had more inventory they lacked quality. I know it's constantly changing though through people selling to Replay, so maybe Toledoans just have better taste?? Prices were very reasonable, lots of stuff for $1.99 or $4.99 and a section of 99¢ DVDs. Staff were friendly and knew their inventory as well. Definitely going to be coming here regularly to see what stuff they get in and get more punches on my card.
Replay LLC is hands down the best place in the area for buying and selling retro games and collectibles. They’re incredibly fair with their prices, whether you're buying or trading in, and it’s clear they really care about both their customers and the gaming community. Every experience I’ve had here has been smooth, honest, and enjoyable — something that's hard to find these days. I can't recommend them enough if you're looking for a place that treats you right and truly values what they do. Thanks, Replay LLC!
traded in a couple of games and was impressed with the amount of store credit I got. Their 99 cent movie selection can’t be beat. This last time I was there I got all the seasons of Dexter (except one missing) for $20!
Sign up to receive exclusive news, updates and restock information.
