Palmetto Cards - Trading Card Shop in Lexington, SC | KeepUp

I called store 3 times during week to explain inventory i wanted to sell and PSA graded cards. Made my expectations clear. PSA - $3,994, PSA’s Buyback offer is even Higher (4K plus) because they are desirable cards such as. Was willing to go for 75% - 80% of average of Both. Was told I had to come in even though registered PSA cards. Took a day off work and drove 3 hours to get offered $800 for everything. Graded cards such as * BOWMAN'S BEST BEST OF 2023 AUTOGRAPHS | BLUE REFRACTOR Max Clark/150 * 2024 BOWMAN CHROME MY 1ST BOWMANPAUL SKENES * 2023-24 PANINI SELECT PREMIER LEAGUE SIGNATURESDAVID BECKHAM - POP 18 CL $491 * 2018 PANINI CHRONICLES SELECT | AQUA ROOKIE CARD [/299]SHOHEI OHTANI 3 - POP 32 - CL $692 * 2023 TOPPS CHROME BLACK IVORY AUTOGRAPHS [/50] Mariono Rivera * 1996 SCORE BOARD BASKETBALL ROOKIES ROOKIE CARDKOBE BRYANT 15 Kobe Bryant * 2024 TOPPS CHROME LOGOFRACTOR EDITION | BLUE REFRACTOR [/150]YOSHINOBU YAMAMOTO * 2022 PANINI OBSIDIAN EQUINOX | ELECTRIC ETCH ORANGE [/35]JALEN WILLIAMS 34 - POP 4 * Had several downtowns - Drake Maye PSA 10, JJ McCarthy Uptown Sealed, Barry Larkin On Campus Sealed - $80 for all 3 * 1/10 Vlad Auto (Not interested in) * Had other high end local cards just as interested Lanoriss Sellars /50, got offered $15) Should remove “Sports”from name. I understand and respect store policies. I actually followed your own guidance — I came prepared with pricing based on PSA, Card Ladder, and eBay comps, added about $20 to account for negotiation, and expected a fair 75–80% buyback range. I even called ahead to confirm what types of cards your store targets and mentioned that my numbers weren’t firm, that I was open to your professional input. I completely understand that not every card fits your local market, but being offered roughly 20% of transparent PSA buyback and comp values — especially after a 3-hour trip — felt disrespectful. I recognize the response here was written for positive optics, and that’s fine, but my review was meant to help other collectors manage expectations before making the same trip. If the store genuinely wants to improve customer service and communication, I’d still be open to a professional conversation about what transpired.

Palmetto Cards

Stay Updated